Benefits Connect Login

Questions and answers about the 2027 Post-Retirement Medical Plan

Here are frequently asked questions and answers about the 2027 Post-Retirement Medical Plan, which will include medical coverage through the UnitedHealthcare Group Medicare Advantage (PPO) plan with Part D prescription drug coverage through Express Scripts Medicare (PDP).

Overview and changes | Eligibility | Enrollment and opting out | Costs and out-of-pocket expenses | Medical benefits and provider networks | Prescription drug coverage | Support and contact information

Overview and changes

Why is the Board changing plans for 2027?

Significant changes in Medicare Advantage funding by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) increased reimbursement-related costs for Medicare Advantage plans. As costs increased, the Board used plan reserves so that plan members paid no premiums in 2025 and 2026. That’s why the Board and Humana mutually agreed to end their contract, effective Dec. 31, 2026. As a result, the Humana Group Medicare Advantage PPO plan and Humana Group Medicare Prescription Drug Plan (PDP) will no longer be offered, beginning Jan. 1, 2027.

After evaluating available options, the Board selected UnitedHealthcare and Express Scripts to provide post-retirement medical and prescription drug coverage for 2027. The Board’s goal in making this selection was to be able to offer high-quality, comprehensive coverage that is substantially equivalent to what retired members have now, at an affordable cost.

Why did the Board choose UnitedHealthcare and Express Scripts?

The Board conducted an extensive evaluation that included plan design, service capabilities, provider access, and overall value. The Board wanted to continue to offer high-quality, comprehensive coverage through a network of providers that is as similar as possible to the current network. The Board also spoke with client references and another organization within the Church Benefits Association about its experience with UnitedHealthcare. Express Scripts has provided prescription drug coverage for the Board’s active members since 2021.

How does the new coverage compare to the coverage through the Humana plans?

Coverage and features are substantially equivalent to what retired members have today through Humana.

Your out-of-pocket costs when filling prescriptions at a retail pharmacy will be the same or less. These include:

  • same $5 copay for up to a 31-day supply of generic medications
  • coinsurance for formulary brand drugs reduced from 30% to 25% for up to a 31-day supply
  • a lower out-of-pocket maximum on the prescription drug plan (there will be a lower cap on the amount you can be required to pay out-of-pocket for covered prescription drugs in a calendar year)

Are additional benefits included with the UnitedHealthcare plan beyond medical coverage?

The UnitedHealthcare Group Medicare Advantage (PPO) plan includes dental, vision, and hearing benefits, as well as Renew Active, a Medicare fitness program offering a gym membership, access to online classes, and activities outside of the gym — all at no additional cost.

Eligibility

What if I previously waived post-retirement medical coverage?

Retired members, spouses, and surviving spouses who previously waived coverage and are not currently enrolled in the Humana plans are not eligible to participate in the Post-Retirement Medical Plan offered through UnitedHealthcare and Express Scripts Medicare.

I am planning to retire in 2026. Can I still enroll in the Humana plan?

Yes, you may enroll in the plan and remain enrolled through 2026. Your coverage will automatically transition to UnitedHealthcare and Express Scripts for 2027, unless you opt out. You can choose coverage for 2027 during the Medicare Open Enrollment period (Oct. 15-Dec. 7, 2026).

Will PC(USA) pastors and staff transition to UnitedHealthcare?

The UnitedHealthcare Group Medicare Advantage (PPO) plan is a retiree health plan. Only those enrolled in the Humana Group Medicare Advantage PPO plan and the Humana Group Medicare Prescription Drug Plan (PDP) will transition to the UnitedHealthcare Group Medicare Advantage (PPO) plan with Express Scripts Medicare (PDP) prescription drug coverage effective Jan. 1, 2027.

Enrollment and opting out

When can I review my options for 2027?

You can review your options during Medicare Open Enrollment, Oct. 15-Dec. 7, 2026. The Board will provide resources and support to help you understand the new plans and make the best decision for your situation.

Will I need to enroll?

You do not need to enroll if you are currently enrolled in the Humana plan. Unless you opt out, you will automatically transition to the UnitedHealthcare Group Medicare Advantage (PPO) plan with Express Scripts Medicare (PDP) prescription drug coverage, effective Jan. 1, 2027. This automatic transition is intended to make the change easier for you and help ensure you do not have a lapse in coverage.

Can I enroll in the UnitedHealthcare Group Medicare Advantage (PPO) plan and not enroll in prescription drug coverage?

Enrollment in the Post-Retirement Medical Plan is for both the UnitedHealthcare and Express Scripts plans. Enrollment in one without the other is not permitted.

How do I opt out of the 2027 Post-Retirement Medical Plan?

We understand that the new plans may not be the right option for everyone. To opt out, call Benistar Admin. Services at 800-236-4782, Monday through Friday, 8:30 a.m.-8 p.m. ET. Benistar can also connect you with expert advisers who can help you find the right coverage for your needs, at no cost to you. During the Medicare Open Enrollment period (Oct. 15-Dec. 7, 2026), you’ll have the opportunity to choose other coverage for 2027 and pay the full cost.

What happens if I opt out of Board-sponsored coverage?

If you opt out, you will not be enrolled in the UnitedHealthcare Group Medicare Advantage (PPO) plan with Express Scripts Medicare (PDP) prescription drug coverage for 2027, and you will not be eligible to enroll in Board-sponsored coverage at a later date unless the Board holds an open enrollment.

Costs and out-of-pocket expenses

How much will coverage cost in 2027?

There will be no monthly premium for 2027. Although the actual premium cost is $284 per covered person per month, the Board will fully subsidize the premium for 2027, so there is no premium cost to you. The Board will determine and share member costs and any potential subsidy for 2028 in summer 2027.

Does the plan still pay 96% for covered services, and I pay 4%?

Instead of paying a percentage of the cost (coinsurance) for your medical care, you pay a set-dollar copay for most covered services. The copay amount depends on the type of service. For example, you pay a $10 copay for a specialist office visit, a $100 copay for outpatient surgery, and a $320 copay for each inpatient hospital stay. View the Summary of Benefits for more details or call Benistar Admin. Services at 800-236-4782, Monday through Friday, 8:30 a.m.-8 p.m. ET.

Copays make it easier to predict your out-of-pocket expenses before you receive care. And because fees vary from provider to provider as well as in different areas of the country, copays ensure all members pay the same amounts for covered services.

Medical benefits and provider networks

Will I have coverage during international travel?

The UnitedHealthcare Group Medicare Advantage (PPO) plan and Express Scripts Medicare include worldwide benefits for emergencies and urgent care situations. When you are outside the U.S., you may need to pay for the services up-front and then submit a claim for reimbursement.

In addition, if you know you will be traveling, you can get up to a 90-day vacation supply of your medication two times a year.

For 2027, you also have access to International SOS services when traveling abroad.

Is physical therapy covered?

The plan covers physical therapy as well as occupational and speech/language therapy. You pay a $10 copay per session.*

Are diabetes insulin pumps and supplies covered? What about continuous glucose monitors (CGMs)?

The UnitedHealthcare Group Medicare Advantage (PPO) plan includes coverage for diabetes testing and monitoring supplies. This includes insulin pumps, CGMs, lancets, lancing devices, and meter replacement batteries. Prescription drug benefits through Express Scripts Medicare include coverage for insulin, needles, and syringes.

Can I get my flu shot at the pharmacy, or do I have to go to my doctor’s office?

You can get some vaccines, including influenza (flu), pneumococcal pneumonia, and COVID-19, at either a participating pharmacy or your doctor’s office. For other vaccines, such as shingles, RSV, and pertussis, you’ll need to go to the pharmacy. Before getting vaccinated, contact Benistar Admin. Services at 800-236-4782 for guidance on where to go for the vaccine to ensure it is covered by the plan.

Will I have to switch my doctors?

Approximately 94% of Humana plan network providers are also UnitedHealthcare network providers.

What happens if my provider does not accept Medicare Advantage plans or participates in Medicare but does not accept UnitedHealthcare?

The UnitedHealthcare Group Medicare Advantage (PPO) plan does not require a provider to have a contract with UnitedHealthcare. Under this plan, the provider will be paid the same as Medicare would pay. Many providers accept this type of plan once they understand they do not need a contract and they will be paid the same as Medicare will pay. UnitedHealthcare will be happy to reach out to your provider to discuss how the plan works and how they will be paid.

Note: Out-of-network/noncontracted providers are under no obligation to treat plan members, except in emergency situations. Please contact Benistar Admin. Services at 800-236-4782 for more information.

Do I have to use a dentist in the UnitedHealthcare Dental Medicare network?

Your dental coverage includes access to a large national network of more than 111,000 dental providers. While you may see any dentist, using a network provider may help you maximize your savings.**

If you have questions about your dental benefits or need help finding a provider, call Benistar Admin. Services at 800-236-4782, Monday through Friday, 8:30 a.m.-8 p.m. ET.

Is there a network I have to use for vision services?

The vision benefit gives you access to a national network of vision providers, while still offering the flexibility to see any participating provider.** You receive a routine eye exam with a network provider each calendar year at a $0 copay.

When scheduling appointments, you should confirm that the provider bills the UnitedHealthcare Group Medicare Advantage (PPO) plan for routine vision services. You may also call Benistar Admin. Services at 800-236-4782 for assistance.

Prescription drug coverage

Will my prescription drugs still be covered?

Prescription drug coverage will be similar to your current coverage. Beginning Jan. 1, 2027, Part D prescription drug coverage will be provided through Express Scripts Medicare as part of the Post-Retirement Medical Plan. If a medication you are currently taking is not on the Express Scripts Medicare formulary, Express Scripts will send you a letter prior to Jan. 1, 2027, suggesting alternative formulary medication for you to discuss with your doctor. Benistar Admin. Services representatives can explain the Express Scripts Medicare plan details and answer any questions you may have.

Are GLP-1 medications for weight loss covered?

GLP-1 medications for weight loss are not covered by Express Scripts Medicare. However, people with Medicare may qualify for access to certain GLP-1 medications, including Foundayo, Wegovy, and Zepbound (KwikPen), through Medicare GLP-1 Bridge, a pilot program launched by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid on July 1, 2026.

To see if you qualify for Medicare GLP-1 Bridge, visit the Medicare website. You can also call 800-MEDICARE (800-633-4227) with questions or to get more information. (TTY users can call 877-486-2048.)

Are over-the-counter drugs covered?

Express Scripts Medicare covers some over-the-counter (OTC) medications, such as vitamins and supplements and cold and flu medications, as well as some lifestyle drugs (excluding weight-loss drugs). To find out if an OTC or lifestyle drug you are taking is covered, call Benistar Admin. Services at 800-236-4782, Monday through Friday, 8:30 a.m.-8 p.m. ET.

Will my mail-order prescriptions with Humana’s CenterWell Pharmacy transfer to Express Scripts?

As long as there are remaining refills and the medication is not a controlled drug, your prescriptions will be transferred to Express Scripts as of Jan. 1, 2027.

Support and contact information

What support will be available to help me make a decision?

You have access to plan materials, prescription drug information, transition support, guidance on next steps, and opportunities to learn more through webinars. In addition, representatives from Benistar are available to answer questions. If you decide the Post-Retirement Medical Plan is not right for you, Benistar can connect you with expert advisers who can help you determine if another Medicare Advantage plan or a supplemental (Medigap) plan may better meet your needs, at no cost to you.

Who should I contact with questions?

Benistar representatives are available Monday through Friday, 8:30 a.m.-8 p.m. ET, at 800-236-4782.

Who is Benistar Admin. Services?

Benistar Admin. Services is a nationally recognized organization that specializes in retiree health benefits offered by organizations like the Board of Pensions. With more than 25 years of experience, they support hundreds of thousands of members and thousands of organizations. The Benistar customer service center is staffed by specialists who are fully trained in Medicare plans. There’s no time limit to your calls — so you can be sure to get your questions answered and feel prepared to make an informed decision. Benistar can be reached at 800-236-4782.

Where can I get more information about the new coverage?

If you’re currently enrolled in the Humana plans, you’ll have received an enrollment package mailed from Benistar to your home address on file in early October. The package will include detailed information about the benefits provided by the UnitedHealthcare Group Medicare Advantage (PPO) plan with Express Scripts Medicare (PDP) prescription drug coverage, along with instructions for opting out of this coverage if you choose.

Will I receive information directly from UnitedHealthcare and Express Scripts?

Yes. In addition to communications from the Board, you will receive information directly from UnitedHealthcare and Express Scripts about your coverage, benefits, enrollment, and other important details as the transition approaches.

Unless you opt out, you’ll receive two separate welcome kits in mid-December, one from UnitedHealthcare and one from Express Scripts. In addition, if a drug you are taking is not on the Express Scripts formulary, you will receive a letter from Express Scripts listing alternative formulary medications for you to consider and discuss with your doctor.

When will I get my new ID cards?

Your UnitedHealthcare medical ID card and Express Scripts prescription drug ID card should arrive before Jan. 1, 2027. Starting Jan. 1, use your UnitedHealthcare ID card when visiting the doctor or other healthcare providers and use your Express Scripts ID card when filling prescriptions. You should securely discard your Humana ID cards after Dec. 31, 2026.

Will Humana send my claims information to UnitedHealthcare and Express Scripts?

Humana will share all claims information with both UnitedHealthcare and Express Scripts prior to Jan. 1, 2027, so they will have all the information they need to process claims in the new year.

*Some network benefits may require your provider to obtain prior authorization. You never need approval in advance for plan-covered services from out-of-network providers. To find out whether a service or drug requires prior authorization, contact Benistar Admin. Services at 800-236-4782.

**When using an out-of-network provider you may be required to pay out-of-pocket at the time of service and then file a claim for reimbursement.